the rising cost of living here

Monday, July 03, 2006

Waiting for my story to clear while saddled with a rare and massive headache, which I've just stupidly compounded by reading my RSS feeds folder titled "Singapore Blogs".

But this is interesting.

mrbrown wrote a column about the rising cost of living in Singapore - a reasonable topic given the recent news about gas/bus/mrt/taxi prices going up.

What may have been a bit less reasonable was the sarcasm he displayed in the piece, in which he insinuated that the news of these price rises had been delayed until after the May elections, for an obvious political agenda:

We are very thankful for the timing of all this good news, of course. Just after the elections, for instance. By that I mean that getting the important event out of the way means we can now concentrate on trying to pay our bills.

It would have been too taxing on the brain if those price increases were announced during the election period, thereby affecting our ability to choose wisely.

The other reason I am glad with the timing of the cost of living increases and wages going down, is that we can now deploy our Progress Package to pay for some of these bills.

Wait, what? You spent it all on that fancy pair of shoes on the day you saw your money in your account? Too bad for you then.

As I break into my Progress Package reserves to see if it is enough to pay the bills, I feel an overwhelming sense of progress. I feel like I am really staying together with my fellow Singaporeans and moving forward.


Maybe he's just trying to be funny; maybe it's the bitterness of a father with an autistic child; maybe he has a point and the govt did indeed plan all this around the elections.

In any case, he incurred the wrath of MICA, who then wrote a very unamused and unhumorous letter in return:

mr brown's views on all these issues distort the truth. They are polemics dressed up as analysis, blaming the Government for all that he is unhappy with. He offers no alternatives or solutions. His piece is calculated to encourage cynicism and despondency, which can only make things worse, not better, for those he professes to sympathise with.

mr brown is entitled to his views. But opinions which are widely circulated in a regular column in a serious newspaper should meet higher standards. Instead of a diatribe mr brown should offer constructive criticism and alternatives. And he should come out from behind his pseudonym to defend his views openly.

It is not the role of journalists or newspapers in Singapore to champion issues, or campaign for or against the Government. If a columnist presents himself as a non-political observer, while exploiting his access to the mass media to undermine the Government's standing with the electorate, then he is no longer a constructive critic, but a partisan player in politics.


The reply is so cliched it's hysterical, in a gotta-laugh-or-you'll-cry way. It conjures up visions of an Orwellian govt machine that churns out standard phrases and sentences in response to key words being fed into it. So if you input "media / political agenda", you get a sentence like "The media should not set the political agenda for this country."

I really don't understand why the govt is so paranoid about the media. I mean, have they actually read it? There is so little in mainstream media to justify any fear about "undermining the Government's standing with the electorate". And how is one supposed to be a "constructive critic" without taking any kind of critical stand? All that talk about how the media should reflect the opinions of the people and not dictate them appears to be bullshit - anyone who writes anything is reflecting some kind of opinion, and if it happens to fall into what the ruling party would define as political dissension, surely we are so much the better for it. Without active and spirited debate, how much progress can we make as a country?

And the thing is, I don't even agree with mrbrown's column. I completely understand the need for a hike in transport and gas prices, given the rising cost of oil and how long it's been since fares rose. Without MICA's response, I would have dismissed the column as just another spoiled Singaporean gripe. But the defensiveness and high-handedness of the reply makes me think there might be something to the conspiracy theories after all.

posted by zyn :: 9:21 PM :: 3 Comments :: permalink


--------------------------------------------------------::--------------------------------------------------------